Dems Ditch Labor. Nothing New.

Yesterday, the president of the American Federation of Government Employees posted on the AFGE website:

This week, Congress pushed our nation into the fourth week of a full government shutdown – an avoidable crisis that is harming families, communities, and the very institutions that hold our country together. Both political parties have made their point, and still there is no clear end in sight.

Today I’m making mine: it’s time to pass a clean continuing resolution and end this shutdown today. No half measures, and no gamesmanship. Put every single federal worker back on the job with full back pay — today.

Illinois Sen Dick Durbin, the Senate Democratic Whip, who is second in leadership to Sen Schumer, replied with a rambling and equivocal statement:

“It has a lot of impact, and they’ve been our friends and we’ve worked with them over the years,” Durbin told reporters on Monday, adding that he has talked to representatives with the union and recognizes that they’re in “a terrible mess” representing so many federal employees who are missing paychecks and facing threats to their jobs.

Still, Durbin told CNN, “I’m not seeing any change in position at this time” as Democrats continue to oppose a bill to extend current funding levels through November 21.

Further,

Sen. Tim Kaine of Virginia, who represents a large population of federal workers, said of the union’s statement, “I work very closely with them. That matters to me. But the issue that I’ve always been focused on, that I’ve shared with y’all is, is a deal, a deal? And the AFGE would not want us to cut a deal and then have Trump fire a bunch of people next week. If we cut a deal and then he did that, they would come to us and say, ‘What the hell were you guys thinking?’”

The real issue, of course, is that the shutdown isn't about federal workers at all, it's about Schumer's poll numbere, AOC, Zohran Mamdani, and who controls the Democrats.

"Chuck Schumer is trading off his polls. What's different than when he passed a clean CR in the spring? It's his polls," says @SecScottBessent on the Democrat Shutdown.

"We're starting to eat into muscle here... I don't know what the purpose is. I'm not sure they do." pic.twitter.com/Bt0ej6d8yF

— Rapid Response 47 (@RapidResponse47) October 26, 2025

For whatever reason, the Senate Democrat leadership has closed ranks with Schumer, even though prospects for his continued career grow dimmer and dimmer:

The Brooklyn Democrat brought in just $133,000 during the three months ending Sept. 30 – while facing a potential primary challenge from “Squad” Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-Bronx and Queens), 36, who raised $4.5 million during the last quarter for her House reelection campaign.

. . . Schumer’s haul was less than half of the $337,000 he brought in during the equivalent period of his 2022 election — his October 2019 report. Senators serve six-year terms and typically ramp up fundraising as their race nears.

He actually spent more on his political operation than he raised from July through September, shelling out $322,000, his latest campaign filing reveals.

The message that's being sent here is something I've been saying about the Democrats for a while: the interests of the working class are no longer a priority, because the Democrats have become an alliance of the upper class and Marx's Lumpenproletariat, once defined as the urban underclass of street criminals, vagabonds, pimps, and prostitutes, but which might now be expanded to include the homeless, drug addicts, illegal migrants, and sexual deviants.

I said during the 2024 campaign that Kamala Harris was the best possible avatar of the new alliance, a woman who dressed in upper-class clothing and accessories while speaking in condescending street argot -- and it was utterly inauthentic; it simply didn't work. This has me scratching my head at the sociopolitical economy of the alliance: many of the modern Lumpenproletariat are ineligible to vote, because they aren't citizens, but whether or not they vote, they don't have the money to donate to candidates.

Unions like the AFGE both vote and donate to campaigns. The trouble is that ever since 1972, labor has been edging away from the traditional Democrat coalition:

As George Meany summoned labor's executive council to decide whether to endorse George McGovern, two national union presidents said today that they would support President Nixon for re‐election because Mr. McGovern's Democratic platform was “unacceptable and repulsive.”

The endorsements of Mr. Nixon by Kenneth T. Lyons of the, 232,000‐member National Association of Government Employes and Jesse M. Calhoon of the 10,000‐member National Marine Engineers Beneficial Association were the first by the heads of any major unions.

The AFL-CIO itself adopted a neutral stance and did not endorse McGovern in the 1972 election. The Teamsters made a similar decision to remaion neutral in the 2024 election. The AFGE is in a similar spot, because on one hand, the government shutdown is delaying paychecks for many of its members, while on the other, its membership covers many traditionally white-collar job types like physicians and administrators.

But the explanations we see above from Sens Durbin and Kaine for why they won't support the members of a major union simply aren't clear -- what, in fact, are they supporting instead? Unspoken is what appears to be the major factor; they're supporting Minority Leader Schumer's wish, however unrealistic it may be, to run for reelection in 2028. But by implication, Schumer will be runnning against AOC and the future of the party, while Sen Schumer is 74, and Dick Durbin is 80.

In effect, the current Democrat leadership is going to age out no matter whether it supports labor or doesn't, but it's likely that the replacements for Schumer and Durbin will resemble AOC and Mamdani more than traditional members of the old Democrat coalition. But the new Democrat alliance of the upper class and the Lumpenproletariat isn't the same majority coalition. This is going to leave the AFGE in a bad spot no matter what.

But here's yet another sign of Trump's political instincts: the shutdown is reaching a point where AFGE members expect the union to work with the Democrats to protect their interests, when the Democrats -- astotishingly short-sighted -- are putting the interests of the upper class and the Lumpenproletariat above the interests of the workers, which will benefit neither the Democrats nor the workers -- and the workers are staring to see it. Right now, it looks like the shutdown is going to kill the Democrat party.