Monday, November 16, 2026

Who Is John Galt?

I've commented here that the Instapundit site is populated by aging libertarians who aren't especially bright, the most prominent of whom is Glenn Reynolds. Libertarians have been trying to tone down their association with Ayn Rand and Objectivism, but Wikipedia stresses that they're closely related:

Although Ayn Rand opposed libertarianism, which she viewed as anti-capitalist, her philosophy of Objectivism has been, and continues to be, a major influence on the right-libertarian movement, particularly libertarianism in the United States. Many libertarians justify their political views using aspects of Objectivism.

Almost 20 years ago, The Huffington Post described Reynolds's and his wife, Helen Smith's, relationship with Ayn Rand and John Galt:

It should come as no surprise that Rand's work, well not her book so much--it's over a thousand boring, boring pages--but rather her fantasy of "Going Galt" by removing yourself from society and thus punishing everybody for their lazy, altruistic impulses, and failure to recognize your genius, that has come back in vogue now that Obama is demonizing the rich and productive by raising their taxes a brutal 3%. Fortunately, unlike the Rapture, Singularity, or similar right-wing escape fantasies, "going Galt" doesn't depend on waiting around for Jesus or Science to smite your enemies. First coined by Dr. Helen Smith, who when pondering an impending Obama victory, asked her readers--who, strangely, all seem to make over 250 grand a year--when it was "time to go Galt." For those who don't know Dr. Helen Smith is a "forensic psychologist"--i.e. works in the criminal justice system--and is married to one Glenn Reynolds, aka Instapundit, the popular glibertarian blogger, who is a law professor at the state-run University of Tennessee. Despite their chosen careers as parasites and collectivists, both Dr. Helen and Reynolds, from their perch at "Pajamas Media" (now accepting donations, Section 8 vouchers, and food stamps), have given voice to the legions of sales reps, middle managers, financial executives, corporate lawyers, and PR consultants, who like John Galt, are fed up with being regulated and taxed for all their indispensable labor, and have now decided to strike back at the government by voluntarily becoming less productive and thus robbing the socialist tyrant of both their funds and more importantly their visionary and clearly irreplaceable skills.

It's taken Instapundit some months, even years, to spin up, but recent criticisms of Elon Musk and Jensen Huang have put Instapundit back into full John Galt mode: Or here:

THIS NEVER GETS OLD:

AOC here is a pure instantiation of Jonathan Swift’s statement: “When a true genius appears in the world, you may know him by this sign, that the dunces are all in confederacy against him.”

Or this:

PROSECUTE ELON MUSK! HE MAKES THE GOVERNMENT LOOK BAD! SpaceX Just Had Another Huge Success.

But wait! Elon's gonna go Galt!

THIS IS PARTLY BECAUSE SPACEX IS TERRIFIC, AND PARTLY BECAUSE EVERYONE ELSE IS BAD. At the Moment, SpaceX IS the Space Launch Industry, and Plans to Leave It Soon. “The bad news is that SpaceX plans to retire the Falcon 9 for commercial launch in the near future and has already stopped taking orders for new trips to orbit. Anyone who wants to get a satellite into space has just lost SpaceX as an option, and, in practical terms, there really isn’t another option. SpaceX has, for all practical purposes, already exited the commercial launch business and the space industry is, rightfully, in a panic.”

I have been assured by great minds like AOC and Matt Stoller that Elon isn’t particularly bright, and that anyone can do this stuff, so I’m sure someone of middling talents will step in and meet the demand. Like it’s hard?

Here's my problem with the idea that Elon Musk and Jensen Huang are modern-day John Galts. Jensen Huang was presumably forced out by the NVIDIA board for precisely the same reason that Bill Gates was forced out by the Microsoft board: he was fishing off the company pier. This sort of thing in a modern corporation is a violation of company policy, as well as sexual harassment law, and subject to various remedies, including termination. That a high-ranking officer would set such a bad example could well lead a board to force even a successful CEO out.

There have been posts at Instapundit and elsewhere that say Musk should simply hire Huang to run his AI. My guess is Musk is smart enough not to do that. I'd wonder if Huang is actually a burnout case, and he's spenidng all his time on his girlfriends; I'd certainly be worried that if I hired him, he'd start right back in on the lower levels of his new org chart. It looks like Musk already has good people where he needs them; Huang would be more trouble than he's worth.

But even if one of Huang's girlfriends turns out not to have been a spy, she worked for an NVIDIA customer, which is a conflict of interest. The board's concerns here are just as legitimate.

Let's also recall that in the spring of 2025, Elon's board was making serious noises that the guy sbould drop all the politics and get back to work, which he pretty promptly did; his board would have forced him out if he hadn't. While this was an indication that Musk did in fact know what he was doing when he was told to do it, it's certainly an indication that the man is considerably less than perfect. He had other flaws in judgment when he bought X, a losing enterprise.

An analysis by The Wall Street Journal earlier this week found that the $13 billion in loans that Musk took from the banks have turned out to be the worst merger-finance deal for lenders since the recession of 2008-2009 — mainly due to the fact that they have been unable to sell the debt to other investors.

The verdict is hardly in on either Huang or Musk, especially as there's concern about an AI bubble bursting. Beyond that, Musk so far -- so far -- appears to have been smart enough at least to keep his trousers zipped on company premises, but the word appears to be that he has something like dozens, if not hundreds, of kids he's fathered via surrogates in various liaisons. This hardly reflects good judgment -- if nothing else, he's got to have something like a full time law firm to just manage all the claims of the surrogates, not to mention the ex-pals.

Roynolds seems to have a knee-jerk impulse to swoon over people he thinks are real-world John Galts.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home