So, Did The Big Guy Order The Raid?
“What I can tell you definitively and for sure, he was not aware of this,” Jean-Pierre said of Biden. “Nobody at the White House was. Nobody was given a heads up and we did not know about what happened yesterday.”
Members of the public who haven't just fallen off the turnip truck will nevertheless say it depends on what the meaning of "definitively and for sure" is, and indeed, those who follow true crime will add that the more redundancies people pile onto their denials, the greater the likelihood that they're false. Others have certainly said that if the above is in fact true, it's proof that someone else is running the show -- but of course, neither assertion necessarily contradicts the other.It's time to update my estimate of what's going on in the First Fuddy-Duddy's head. My view all along has been that his problem isn't medical, and a medical diagnosis from a distance is meaningless in any case. At the same time, I was an English major, have lived my whole life without a course in psychology, and I am not a mental health professional. Even if I were, the same applies to any such diagnosis made from a distance. Nevertheless, there are plenty of evaluative tools available, even for use from a distance, that can shed insight into character without wandering into quasi-diagnostic jargon.
Let's start with one of the most traditional, the concept refined by St Thomas Aquinas of the seven deadly sins, pride, anger, lust, envy, gluttony, avarice, and sloth. As far as I can see, just about the only one of which the big guy appears to be innocent is gluttony; he's pretty skinny, and his only weakness in that department seems to be ice cream cones.
On the other hand, pride, which might also translate into a lack of insight or self-awareness, has pretty clearly got to be close to the top of the list. The guy is one of the shallowest people in public life. Pride would also be reflected in a sense of entitlement, in particular the expectation that his entourage of yes-men and enablers will always clean up after his bumbling misspeaks and explain his lacunae of judgment. It's possible, as I've sometimes speculated, that alcohol could be feeding this, but like Speaker Pelosi, Biden claims not to drink. But then, his staff claims on his behalf that he knew nothing of the raid. None of these denials rings tue.
Anyhow, if he isn't drinking, the side effects of prescription drugs might also account for the haze, or simple habit borne of laziness or sloth. Clear expression in speech or writing takes a certain level of discipline, and indeed self-awareness. The need to proofread and edit one's own writing is a habit that comes from self-awareness, as is the need for prudence, clarity, and reserve in speech. I doubt if he ever acquired either, and neither was ever required of him.
Certainly sloth is a clear factor in his wish to escape from the White House at every opportunity.
I think, though, that we're getting closer to the issue of the raid when we get to anger and envy. At least some observers have pointed out that pretty much throughout his presidency to date, Trump has beaten Biden in prospective 2024 matchups. If we assume Biden has no situational awareness, this wouldn't be a factor, but my guess is that the laziness and entitlement that drive his public persona are masquerading as senility. Under the fuddy-duddy mask is an angry, petty, and vindictive guy.
I think we can also bring the Aristotelian virtues of prudence, justice, temperance, and fortitude into play. All of these contribute to what more recent analysis of character would characterize as impulse control. At this point I'm starting to see parallels to Nixon's character flaws that led to the Watergate scandal -- people who knew him during that period indicate that when he grew tired, he would drink too much, which led to cascading bouts of anger and vindictiveness.
Thus in Nixon's case we had the Saturday Night Massacre of October 1973, which led directly to the Watergate committee and his resignation less than a year later under the threat of impeachment. I think the Saturday Night Massacre and the Mar-a-Lago raid, which have at this point both been characterized as overreaches, have similar roots in simmering anger, and in Biden's case jealousy of Trump, who even as a lower-key figure in the period of more than a year afer leaving office remains a formidable electoral threat.
The overriding question for both Nixon and Biden is whether their weaknesses in character led to self-destructive errors in judgment. My estimate in Biden's case is that while Nixon was likely not specifically aware of the initial Watergate burglary and didn't order it (although lower level staff like Colson did), Biden probably initiated, approved, and ordered the Mar-a-Lago raid or something essentially like it. That will make it a potentially much more serious matter.
