There's A Puzzling Essay By Thodore Dalrymple At City Journal
City Journal, which did a great deal to illuminate the problems caused by Temporary Protected Status for Haitians, Venezuelans, and others in the runup to the 2024 election, seems a lot less willing to explain anything at all in an essay by the pseudonymous Theodore Dalrymple (AKA Anthony Malcolm Daniels, a retired psychiatrist and conservative cultural critic), Britain’s Crisis of Governance: Small groups of motivated ideologues have imposed their views on a hostile populace.
As a non-Briton trying to understand the news from the other side of the world, this does nothing to help me understand why the UK is unable to protect itself from mass third-world migration via dinghies, instead housing the migrants in hotels and subsidizing them while they wait for years to have their spurious asylum cases adjudicated. This must certainly be the single, highest-profile political issue in the country, but he makes no direct mention of it at all.
Let's start with the issues he does mention, in order. I'll grant that all of these are bizarre and self-destructive, but I still think they're of secondary importance to mass migration. First, energy policy:
In an act of moral grandiosity, Britain adopted a legally binding net-zero carbon-emissions policy, enacted in 2019 by a Conservative—or nominally conservative—government. Yet Britain emits considerably less than 1 percent of the world’s greenhouse gases, so eliminating its emissions altogether would have no discernible effect on global warming (even assuming that such warming is entirely the product of greenhouse-gas emissions).
But there's potentially a whole subsidiary issue he doesn't mention: In 2024, Britain eliminated the use of coal in electricity generation, and it is actively working to eliminate coal from other industrial use. Let's consider that George Orwell's 1937 The Road to Wigan Pier outlined the extent to which industrial revolution Britain relied on coal and contrasted it with the terrible conditions under which miners worked and lived. The postwar Labour nationalization of the coal industry might have been expected to ameliorate this, but instead, the policy was to import cheap labor from the former empire to continue conditions of low pay.And then the ruling class of all parties simply eliminated coal as a problem, replacing it with imported Muslim workers. Dalrymple doesn't mention this glaring incongruity at all. Instead, next, of all things, high speed rail:
A high-speed rail line between London, Manchester, and Leeds was first proposed in 2009 and approved in 2012. Yet the first trains—on the truncated route between London and Birmingham—are not expected to run until sometime between 2033 and 2036. If the project’s habitual delays are any guide, the later date would be the safer prediction.
Ho-hum, California has precisely the same problem, nothing uniquely British about this. He explains the cause as
Wherever one looks in Britain, one sees the division of responsibilities, the proliferation of organizations, and the multiplication of procedures, supposedly to prevent mistakes or corruption but, in reality, manifestations of what one could call legalized corruption. The official British inquiry into the handling of the Covid-19 pandemic will, by the time it concludes, have taken more than four years and cost 200 times as much as Sweden’s, which reported after just two years. Does anyone imagine that its findings will therefore be 200 times as thorough, wise, honest, or intellectually sound because it cost 200 times as much? On the contrary, like most modern official inquiries, the British inquiry became a trough at which lawyers, officials, and experts could feed.
He then ties this to the degradation of police, which is as close as he comes to the problem of mass migration:
The recent shocking case of Henry Nowak, the young student arrested while dying from stab wounds after being falsely accused of making racist remarks, was only an extreme example of what we have come to expect from our police, whom much of the population now view as lazy, incompetent, malicious, and stupid (too often with reason—though, of course, not always).
. . . The stupidity of police behavior, from the lowest to the highest echelons, is not caused by a lack of intelligence or brainpower. It is the effect of what might be called artificial unintelligence, which has proved more destructive in its effects than anything AI has so far managed. The minds of many police officers have been colonized, as if by a mental virus or prion: ideas, or fragments of ideas, that induce a permanent state of fear, usually subliminal until reality intrudes, when that fear prevents them from confronting it honestly. Senior police officers become political apparatchiks, preserving their self-respect by professing belief in ideological shibboleths: not those of the general population, or even of a majority, but of its hyperactive monomaniacs and ideological entrepreneurs.
But can we trace a cause of all this? He throws out the "spread of higher education", which might be a productive path, but to do that, you'd have to take a closer look at what was happening in UK higher education over prior decades, for instance the Cambridge spies and what led them to betray their country. But that's too big a topic, and he simply drops it. Instead, he substitutes what seems like a less productive conclusion:
Yet peaceful though my town may be, it is not without other problems. Its high street and many of its other roads, for example, are badly pitted with potholes after years of neglected maintenance. The town and county councils merely paint a white line around each pothole, thereby absolving themselves, legally, of responsibility for damage to vehicles that strike them. But the condition of the roads has never aroused anything like the passion provoked by the question of flying the rainbow flag from a municipal building. Sectional interest triumphs over the common interest.
. . . This reflects a fundamental problem—not unique to Britain, but particularly acute there: an ever-weaker sense of a common identity, especially among the politically active, that binds together the demos of a democracy and enables it to deal peacefully with differences. In a world of multiple ideologies, competing though sometimes forming tactical coalitions, being Muslim is, for Muslims, the most important thing, or the only thing; being a woman is, for some women, the most important thing; being homosexual is, for some homosexuals, most important; reducing greenhouse-gas emissions is, for environmentalists, the overriding concern; and so on almost ad infinitum.
But aren't the advocates of Restore Britain, particularly when they march with the pre-1707 English flag with St George's Cross, attempting to restore a common sense of national purpose? Why else are they denounced by all the best elements as too working-class and racist?I keep returning to the problem of the 1926 UK General Strike, in which the middle and upper classes promulgated a fantasy that they were able to overcome the strikers by simply volunteering to drive the buses and run the trains, which in fact they were never actually able to do. But more recenty. I've come to see that the UK upper and middle classes have widely promulgated another myth, that the Battle of Britain was won by heroic "winged Arthurs", again of the upper and middle classes.
One of the most persistent myths is that the majority of fighter pilots that took part in the BoB were public school educated. A myth reinforced by the accents of the actors that portrayed such pilots in the films that later dramatised the battle. (Think Kenneth Moore, Michael Caine, Christopher Plummer etc, speaking the King/Queen’s English).
One of the first films to portray the public school boy hero was the ‘First of the Few’. The film was made with the help of Auxiliary Air Force Pilots and did indeed have a high proportion of public school boys in it’s rank. The myth escalated from there. In fact of the 2900 pilots that fought, only 200 came from public schools. Around 20% were non British, but the overwhelming majority were young, home grown men, that came from more humble backgrounds. It is a shame that this fact is still overlooked.
It seems to me that there's an unspoken elephant in the whole UK room, that low-wage workers from the former empire were imported, beginning in the postwar years, either to replace or keep wages down for the working class in key industries that had been nationalized by the postwar Labour government. In effect, this was simply a betrayal of the working class by Labour. Current attitudes toward mass migration seem to be affected by an unwillingness to face this, and "Theodore Dalrymple" seems to be of this group himself. He senses that there's a missing sense of common identity, while the UK ruling classes have been pushing their own spurious sense of common identity for well over a century.



