Let's Take A Closer Look At Candace Owens
A visitor very kindly sent me several links about Candace Owens and her husband, George Farmer. Farmer, the wealthy son of a member of the UK House of Lords, converted to Catholicism in 2018, and almost immediately after his conversion, he married Owens:
Farmer explains he first met Owens on December 11, 2018 [after a UK Charlie Kirk appearance where she shared the stage], eating dinner together the next night. He had a life-changing “God moment” one week later, on December 18. He proposed 11 days after his God moment, on December 29: “Nothing had been said. There had been no romantic overtures at all at this point.”
“It had all been very above board, talking about politics and engaging in philosophical conversations, and at the end of December, I called her a couple of times to kind of chat and again, had these prolonged conversations, mainly about politics and trying to understand what she wanted to do in life.”
By December 29, 2018 (18 days after meeting her), he was flying to Africa for New Year’s when he called Owens and said, “Listen, I know this is completely crazy, and we just met, but how do you feel about getting married to me?”
Two things seem incongruous to me here. The first is that the four Catholic cardinal virtues, prudence, justice, fortitude, and temperance, would argue against whirlwind courtships and whirlwind conversions, yet this is just what we see here. In addition, at least in the US, formal conversion to Catholicism normally takes place via the Rite (now Order) of Christian Initiation for Adults, a year-long process of catechesis that ends at the Easter Vigil. A web search tells me the process in the UK is substantially the same, except that it continues to use the acronym RCIA, and it also ends at the Easter Vigil.So all we know about George Farmer's conversion is that it took place during a "God moment" in the UK in December, 2018, and it doesn't seem to have involved the Easter Vigil. So exactly how did he convert, and at what parish did he enter the Church in her eyes? That's my second question.
But now we come to Candace Owens herself and her own conversion to Catholicism. According to the National Catholic Reporter,
The firebrand conservative commentator Candace Owens has announced her conversion to Catholicism, a long-expected move for the controversial 34-year-old Black ideologue.
She announced the news on social media Monday afternoon (April 22 [2024]), describing it as a "decision to go home."
. . . The change for Owens comes amid shifting sands in her professional life, including an acrimonious exit from The Daily Wire in March following statements she made and supported that were seen as antisemitic.
. . . Long identified as a Reformed Evangelical Protestant, in recent years Owens began speaking more frequently about Catholicism, not least because of her convert husband, the British activist and former Parler CEO George Farmer, whom she married in 2019.
. . . Owens revealed that she regularly attended Mass with Farmer and their children but was not yet decided on making a denominational change. By March of this year, however, in response to a social media post asking if she is Catholic, she responded, "Almost there."
Some interpreted Owens' response as an indication that she would be received into the Catholic Church at the Easter Vigil, but there was no announcement forthcoming from the Nashville-based pundit. [In 2024, the Easter Vigil took place on March 30, but her announcement wasn't made until late April.]
In her social media announcement post this week, she is seen with the Oratorian priest Julian Large and a large vigil candle in her husband’s native London at the Brompton Oratory, a Latin Mass community established by St. John Henry Newman in 1849.
So again, precisely how, when, and where was she received into the Catholic Church, and how extensive was her catechesis? But no matter where and how it occurred, it pretty clearly took place not long after her split with Ben Shapiro and her departure from Daily Wire, and that also accompanied a major change in her public stance toward Israel and the Jews. In late March 2024, The Guardian reported:
The far-right commentator Candace Owens left the rightwing Daily Wire website amid tensions over her alleged antisemitism and opposition to US funding of Israel’s war in Gaza.
. . . Owens has criticised US support for Israel but also mused about “political Jews” and a “very small ring of specific people who are using the fact that they are Jewish to shield themselves from any criticism”, remarks Shapiro called “absolutely disgraceful”.
On Monday, on social media, Owens liked a post in which a user asked Shmuley Boteach, a well-known rabbi, if he was “drunk on Christian blood again”.
Owens subsequently came under fire from the Anti-Defamation League. The ADL, which campaigns against antisemitism, posted a report by the progressive watchdog Media Matters about remarks in which Nick Fuentes, a Holocaust denier and white supremacist, praised Owens for mounting “a full-fledged war against the Jews”.
The so-called "blood libel" is, of course, full-blown anti-Semitism, and at minimum, it's unfortunate that it's emerging at the same time that Owens is publicly embracing Catholicism. According to a March 2024 piece at The Times of Israel,
In recent months, Owens has also attacked Shapiro – who originally platformed her on his Daily Wire website – as a “Talmudic Jew,” urging her listeners to buy a discredited antisemitic screed from the 19th century. She has also claimed that Jews were behind the transatlantic slave trade, and that “they believe they have a right to own us.” She has called Israel an “occult nation,” pointing as evidence to the Star of David on its flag (a “cultic…hexagram”), and has suggested Israel was behind the assassination of John F. Kennedy.
During the same period, she's attacked "Christian Zionists":
Candace Owens, a voice many Christians have trusted for cultural commentary, has made some extraordinarily serious claims about Calvary Chapel churches. . . . [S]he suggests . . . that Calvary Chapel has been “infiltrated” by military and intelligence operatives, that we’re part of a coordinated psychological operation designed to manufacture “Christian Zionists,” and that what appears to be a move of God is actually a carefully orchestrated deception stretching back to the 1960s.
. . . In her broadcasts, Candace weaves together an intricate tapestry: MK Ultra mind control programs, Britney Spears’ conservatorship battles, Jeffrey Epstein’s crimes, various financial scandals, Turning Point USA’s internal conflicts, Hollywood’s darkness… and then, somehow, Calvary Chapel pastors and churches.
The connecting tissue? Military backgrounds. Financial connections. A “feeling” that something isn’t right. The sense that too many scandals orbit around certain names and places.
This for me raises the question of how well-catechized either Owens's husband, George Farmer, and Owens herself were before they converted to Catholicism, and indeed, whether they were formally received at all. Consider the reported remarks of Pius XI on September 6, 1938:
Through Christ and in Christ we are the spiritual descendants of Abraham. No, it is not possible for Christians to take part in antisemitism. We acknowledge for all the right to defend themselves, to adopt measures of protection against what threatens their legitimate interests. But antisemitism is inadmissible. Spiritually, we are Semites.
She claims to attend mass with her husband and children, but if she pays any attention at all to the readings and likely the homilies, she's got to get the impression that a pretty big slice of the Christian Bible covers the spiritual struggles of the Jews in conquering and trying to keep the Promised Land. So I think it's legitimate to question the sincerity of her conversion. Indeed, even her father-in-law, Lord Michael Farmer, became publicly uncomfortable in August 2024:
Farmer, a big-money donor to Conservative Party politicians in the UK, wrote that he was “very aware of the cruelty meted out” against Jews both before and during the World War II period when he came of age.
“The best man at my wedding and life-long friend was Jewish,” Farmer wrote, adding that he valued the “kindness and thoughtfulness from Jewish friends … at a time when I had few close relationships.”
Farmer, a member of the House of Lords, which is the upper chamber of the UK parliament, went on to praise Israel as a “rare example of a democracy in the Middle East.”
“Of course, it has the right to defend its citizens when murderously attacked on its soil in one of the cruelest and most callous pogroms in history,” Farmer wrote, referencing the Oct. 7 terrorist attacks by Hamas which left nearly 1,200 Israeli soldiers and civilians dead and scores more in Hamas captivity.
Her husband, George, has been remarkably subdued amid all this controversy, and I almost detect a faint echo of Meghan Markle and Prince Harry. There are lots of people lately who make a big deal of their public Catholicism -- but what's puzzled me for some years is how few people like that I actually run into at our parish. There are public Catholics, Catholics who star at Catholics for Catholics galas, Catholics who hold forth on social medai -- but then, there are just Catholics.I wonder how soon Candace in particular will move on to something else.






