Speaking of Nithya Raman
In yesterday's post, I mentioned that although Nithya Raman won tbe LA mayor's election while identifying as a Democratic Socialist, the Democratic Socialists have begun to complain that she isn't much of one:
As Nithya Raman prepares to become the first mayor of Los Angeles affiliated with the Democratic Socialists of America, that connection reveals a lot about the city electorate and surprisingly little about what we can expect from her.
. . . Raman’s victory put a democratic socialist in office, but she comes to her post so at the edge of that movement that it’s difficult to tell how much of its program she will implement.
She is not a West Coast replica of New York’s Zohran Mamdani, as was often observed during the campaign. She does not propose rent freezes or free public transit or city-owned grocery stores or a pied-à-terre tax on second homes — the pillars of Mamdani’s New York platform.
Raman’s ambitions are far less sweeping. She talks like the urban planner she is, trilling over the nuts and bolts of government, promising accountability and transparency. She vows to patch potholes and fix streetlights. She supported the city’s so-called “mansion tax” but also believes it needs amending to correct some of the downward pressure it has put on new housing construction.
. . . But the electorate’s historic move to the left may test even Raman’s socialism-lite, underscored by the uneasy relationship the mayor-elect has with the Democratic Socialists of America. The Los Angeles chapter endorsed her in September, but the organization’s national committee came within one vote of rescinding that endorsement just days before the election because it questioned whether Raman was, well, socialist enough.
One test: Will Raman deliver an overhaul of the Los Angeles Police Department, starting with the removal of its chief, as many of her allies demand? Or will she opt for stability in the run-up to the 2028 Olympics, as many of her more moderate supporters would like to see?
For now, as I've already noted, Raman looks like she isn't going to remove LAPD Chief McDonnell, at least not right away:
The LAPD needs more mental health professionals to help respond to 911 calls, Chief Jim McDonnell told the California Post in an exclusive interview — a tactic mayor-elect Nithya Raman has pledged to support as the two try to bury the hatchet and address the city’s mental-health crisis.
The chief met with Raman Thursday [November 12] for a “get to know each other” session as they hunted for common ground on policing and public safety, finding a place for agreement on the point that too many cops are wasting their time trying to help out the city’s mentally ill.
“The mayor is in alignment with the way we’re doing business, as far as trying to be able to get increased civilianization and expertise to deal with issues such as people experiencing a mental health crisis,” McDonnell told The Post. The chief is trying to hang onto his job after Raman pledged to replace him on the campaign trail.
. . . Raman has said she wants more unarmed crisis response pros accompanying cops on calls as part of her first 100 day public safety plan, which also includes more 911 operators and an LAPD audit.
As far back as October, Raman had said she will not remove McDonnell during her first 100 days, and she's been vague about the precise time she'll do it. One concern is that firing McDonnell would cause a mass exodus of LAPD officers before the 2028 Olympics. This has been causing a break with the DSA:
Yes, Raman is a socialist, and sought the DSA’s endorsement for LA mayor. But the DSA is not trying to make her job any easier. Instead, it’s issuing threats.
As The California Post reported, the DSA of Long Beach issued a warning to the mayor-elect last week: Obey our agenda, or else.
However, the City of Long Beach is a separately incorporated municipality from the City of Los Angeles and elects its own mayor. The link continues,
“We call on her to govern as part of the movement that got her elected, not at arm’s length from it,” the DSA warned.
The DSA’s top priority? Taking action on “Palestine.”
It’s not enough for the DSA that Raman falsely accused Israel of “genocide.” The DSA wants her to cut off LA’s “economic support for a genocidal apartheid state,” whatever that means.
The DSA also wants Raman to keep her pledge to fire LAPD chief Jim McDonnell, and to impose further rent controls.
If she does not comply, the DSA warns, “we’ll bring the fight to her.”
But from Long Beach? Why not elect a DSA mayor in Long Beach instead? The bottom line question for Raman is whether the whole mayoral election was just a vanity project, or whether she wants to be a successful mayor, and so far, this is by no means clear:
Los Angeles mayor-elect Nithya Raman is still living up to the “No-Show Nithya” nickname given to her during her campaign for mayor.
Raman has missed multiple City Council and committee meetings since the Nov. 3 election, including back-to-back council sessions just this week, despite vowing to finish her term.
Raman was absent from council meetings on both Tuesday and Wednesday, missing key city business involving public safety, homelessness and more than $200,000 in proposed improvements within her own district.
An editorial in the California Post makes the point:
The residents of District 4 — which includes parts of Hollywood and the San Fernando Valley — had six years of experience with Raman as their representative on the City Council.
And that was enough for most of them, apparently, to stick with Karen Bass as mayor.
It’s no surprise: You could see the tension between Raman and her constituents when the Sherman Oaks Homeowners Association hosted a mayoral debate in August.
Questions from the residents showed clear frustration with Raman’s leadership. They faulted her for allowing street vendors to undercut brick-and-mortar restaurants, for example, and for neglecting single-family homes.
They delivered their verdict on November 3. But it doesn’t have to be the final verdict.
. . . Raman may have academic training as an urban planner, but you can’t run a big city from the faculty lounge or a drafting table.
You have to make bold decisions. You have to walk among the people.
So commentators are hopeful that she'll break with the DSA and govern pragmatically -- but the likelihood still exists that she'll break with the DSA, but only to hold the mayor's office as a vanity project.



