Rubio Edges Out Vance In 2028 Poll
Via yesterday's Emerson poll,
Secretary of State Marco Rubio holds a double-digit lead over Vice President JD Vance in a hypothetical race for the 2028 Republican nomination, according to a new national poll released Thursday — a complete reversal from 12 months ago.
A plurality (44%) of Republican primary voters who responded to the Emerson College survey picked Rubio from a list that included Vance (24%), Florida Gov. Ron DeSantis (9%), Donald Trump Jr. (6%) and broadcaster Tucker Carlson (5%).
. . . In November of last year, Vance led Rubio by nearly 50 percentage points (54% to 6%) in the open-ended version of the Emerson poll.
Vance is considered by many to be the favorite for the Republican nomination, should he seek it. The VP has said he’ll decide on his political future next year, with Axios reporting he may not announce until late spring 2027. Meanwhile, CNN reported last week that Vance is seriously considering sitting the race out.
Vance's post-mortem on the midterms seems to have damaged his prospects badly. Why this should be the case is a puzzle: his shorthand list of the reasons we lost was- End the war
- Focus on cost of living/inflation
- Put America First
- Change our relationship to Israel
But let's look at another factor. I've been noting that voters want to see new faces. For instance, Nithya Raman beat old face Karen Bass in the LA mayoral election, not so much because she's a Democratic Socialist -- the DSA has begun complaining that she's turning out not to be very DSA at all -- but because she's an optimistic new face. Midterm winners like James Talarico, Annie Andrews, and Troy Jackson are at least arguably optimistic new faces.
The same Emerson poll puts another relatively new Democrat face at the top, but old faces are runners-up in plenty:
On the Democratic side, Sen. Jon Ossoff (D-Ga.) tops the field with 17% support in the close-ended poll, followed by former Vice President Kamala Harris (16%), Bronx and Queens Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (15%) former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg (14%), and California Gov. Gavin Newsom (11%).
Ossoff's problem as a Democrat is that he's Jewish; otherwise, an equivalent optimistic pretty face would do well, especailly against Vance, whose problem is that he looks like he belongs on a Smith Brothers cough drop package, but without the beard, he's baby faced. Rubio is starting to come off as a real mensch, and beyond that, a Machiavellian, which is what Republicans will need going forward:Look at the runners-up to Ossoff in the Democrat poll, other than Ossoff, the rest are old faces. My guess is that for 2028, the Democrats are going to re-run their 2020 strategy and run a cipher as a "moderate", get him into the White House and let a bunch of radical insiders set policy while the cipher stays on medication or the bottle. The two best candidates for cipher right now are Kamala Harris and Gavin Newsom. I think Rubio is smart enough and Machiavellian enough to run circles around either.CNN: Marco Rubio is weighing a run for president in 2028. Rubio previously pledged to support JD Vance. He has now declined to renew that commitment. His allies and Republican donors are increasingly pushing him to consider a bid. Doubts over Vance have grown since the party's midterm defeat.
— Open Source Intel (@Osint613) November 19, 2026
Not only that, but Rubio as Machiavellian is a completely new concept, 180 degrees from the "Little Marco" label Trump was able to pin on him in 2016.

